In early July the Consumer Price Index (CPI) was
released for June. It remained unchanged for a second consecutive month. The CPI is the
most widely watched gauge of inflation. On June 30, the last day of the second quarter,
the Federal Reserve (Fed) raised the Federal Funds Rate 1/4% as a preemptive strike
against any inflationary pressures building in the economy.
The financial markets normally would have been relieved with such a
benign CPI report. However, the stock market began to decline in mid July, and hit its low
point in early August. Wall Street again exhibited its own logic difficult to understand
for most investors. The underlying reason for the stock market decline, when no apparent
inflationary pressures exist for the economy, is the comments that the Federal Reserve
Chairman Alan Greenspan, continues to release to the public. These comments are in
reference to his fears of the tight labor market that exists for the US economy . On
August 24, the Fed again raised short term interest rates another 1/4 %, further confusing
stock and bond investors as to the Feds next move at their Oct 5 meeting.
The Feds action of raising interest rates seems at odds with the US
Treasury. Lawrence Summers, the new Treasury Secretary, released information to the press
in early August that the Treasury may buy back some of its bonds to trim debt.
Summers said buying back debt could have many benefits for the US
economy and the government, including lowering interest costs and enhancing liquidity.
"Enhancing the liquidity to the Treasurys benchmark
securities should lower the government interest costs over time and promote market
liquidity" Summers said at a news conference.
It appears that the Fed is determined to keep interest rates high,
while the Treasury is trying to lower interest rates. This dichotomy is not very
reassuring to the investment community, that is always seeking some logic and certainty in
reference to the actions of the government and its agencies.
Perhaps the actions and desires of both the Fed and the Treasury will
align soon, providing the government with a common agenda to help the US economy grow,
while at the same time keeping prices stable.
This backdrop of uncertainty has kept the stock market trading in a
range since mid May. There has been tremendous daily volatility since then. However, the
market by mid September was trading about where it started out in mid May. The summer
rally never happened.
To add insult to injury, many internet stocks as well as internet IPO's
dropped precipitously in early August.
In the last week of September the stock market tried to regain its
composure . Investors however, seemed spooked by the recent rise in gold prices and the
weakness in the bond market.
In late September the Federal Reserve released its "Beige-
Book" a report on the economy. This "Beige-Book" compiled by the Feds
dozen district banks, said that every region in the US continued to exhibit "overall
strength" while there were "few reports" of accelerating wages and
salaries.
Wall Street economists welcome the pairing of rising business activity
and flat wages, since the Fed views higher wages as a key part of potential future
inflation. The current "Beige-Book" survey, based on data recorded in August and
September, is intended as a guide to regional economic conditions ahead for the next Fed
meeting on October 5.
This "Beige-Book" revealed a healthy economy, with little if
any inflationary pressures building. This reinforces the view that Alan Greenspans
recent speeches regarding his concern about rising inflationary pressures in the future,
may have only been cautionary or simply misplaced.
Wall Street however, does not tolerate uncertainty about the future
actions of the Fed and as such, this uncertainty has been a catalyst for the poor
performance of the stock market in the third quarter of 1999.
Adding more uncertainty to the financial landscape are two other
factors. The first being the decline of the US dollar against the Japanese Yen, and the
second being the recent escalation of the price of gold.
In mid 1995 the fear was that the Yen would continue to appreciate
against the dollar. The exchange rate of the Yen versus the US dollar was 80 Yen to the
dollar. At that time the consensus of the international banking community was hoping for a
weakening of the Yen to 100 Yen per dollar, which consequently is where the Yen versus the
dollar is today.
In mid 1998 the fear was that the Yen was too weak when it was trading
at 150 Yen to the US dollar. Today the fear is the Yen is too strong, even though it is
trading at a level sought by economists in 1995.
There are pros and cons of having a strong or weak currency. The
financial markets overreacted to the Yen strengthening versus the dollar recently, as the
dollar is quite strong against most other foreign currencies. The dollar weakening versus
the Yen can actually be beneficial for the US economy, as US exports will be cheaper in
Japan, which bolsters the gross domestic product for the US. The strengthening Yen is
potentially harmful to the Japanese economy because it raises the price of the goods they
export. This might delay the recovery of the Japanese economy which has been languishing
for almost ten years.
The recent rise in gold prices should have little if any impact on the
US economy. On September 27, fifteen European central banks announced to the news media
that they will not be unloading extra gold onto the market for at least five years. Gold
prices have been trading between two hundred fifty and three hundred dollars per ounce
since early 1998. On September 27, gold rose fourteen dollars per ounce, closing at about
$281 per ounce. The next day gold went up an additional $26 per ounce closing over three
hundred dollars per ounce.
Gold prices are no longer used as a barometer for inflation, therefore
its price has a minimal affect on the overall stock and bond market.
If the Fed doesnt blunder in the future, continuing corporate
earnings growth, and low inflation should help the stock market in the last quarter of
1999. Next year in 2000 when Y2K fears have subsided, the bull may return to Wall Street.